Atg Logo Vector

Video: Women Engineers Read Rejection Letters from 1919

Boeing asked women engineers to read on camera letters found in SWE's archives explaining why women could not be admitted to engineering schools in 1919.
Video: Women Engineers Read Rejection Letters From 1919

For the Society of Women Engineer’s Founders Day at the end of May, we published a series of letters from SWE’s archives from university deans and professors explaining why women could not be admitted into engineering schools in 1919. Now, to draw attention to the fact that today only 13% of engineering jobs in the U.S. are held by women, Boeing has asked some of its women engineers to read those letters on camera. Watch the video above to see their reactions and read below to learn more about the letters.

Letters from SWE’s Archives

Troy Eller English has been SWE’s archivist for nine years. One of her favorite stories in the archives comes from 1919 when two University of Colorado engineering students sent letters to U.S. colleges of engineering asking if any female students had been enrolled in the past or present. Those Colorado students, Lou Alta Melton and Hilda Counts, were trying to start the American Society of Women Engineers and Architects (ASWEA), a precursor to SWE, and they were looking for potential members. They sent letters to every engineering and architecture department they could find, asking for information about any women who had taken courses.

Video: Women Engineers Read Rejection Letters From 1919

SWE’s archives contain some remarkable letters from deans and professors replying to Melton and Counts. To give these letters some historical context, in 1919, most American engineering societies did not accept women as full members, and women were not admitted into many colleges. These letters were written just after World War I ended, and as the 19th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which gave women the right to vote, was being ratified. The 19th Amendment passed the House and Senate in 1919. Tennessee was the last state of 36 needed to approve it, and that didn’t happen until August 18, 1920.

Some letters in response to the survey cited the law and school policy against admitting women to engineering schools. Click on the sender’s name to see and read the actual letter.

February 5, 1919

“We do not permit women to register in the Engineering School under our present regulations.”

William Mott, Dean, Carnegie Institute of Technology

February 7, 1919

“Under our State system of higher education, women are not admissible to the University of Florida, nor men to the Florida State College for Women at Tallahassee. While the State College at Tallahassee does not have any engineering departments, it does offer courses in applied science.”

R. Benton, Dean, College of Engineering, University of Florida

Some of those who replied expressed doubt in the ability for Melton and Counts to find enough women who were interested in engineering to form a society.

Feb. 4, 1919

“You ask for information or suggestions. I have only this say, that I suspect the number of women who have undertaken general engineering courses is so few that you will hardly be able to form an organization. However, I may be mistaken. 

Yours very truly,

William Raymond, Dean, College of Applied Science, The State University of Iowa

May 12, 1919

“In reply to your recent communication, I would state that we have not now, have never had, and do not expect to have in the near future, any women students registered in our engineering department.” 

Yours very truly,

Thorndike Saville, Associate Professor, The University of North Carolina

Some noted that times were changing.

May 7, 1919

Up to the present, women students have not been admitted to GA Tech. Yesterday, the City of Atlanta conferred suffrage on women in City Affairs, so no knowing what may happen!”


J.S. Coon, Professor Mechanical Engineering, Georgia School of Technology

May 6, 1919

“Replying to your letter of May 2, beg to say we have never had, in the University of Arkansas, a woman to register for a serious course in Engineering… I am aware that in the Northern and Eastern Colleges often girls register for Engineering work and make very excellent students.”

W. N. Gladson, Dean, College of Engineering, The University of Arkansas

One of the most hopeful letters sent to Melton and Counts came from a student at the University of Michigan who explained that the women engineering students there had formed their own organization called T-Square Society.

May 7, 1919

“The women students in Engineering and Architecture at the University of Michigan are pleased to hear from women studying the same things in Colorado. In 1914 we ascertained that there was then no society organized for women students in engineering and architecture, and at the time formed a society with the approval of the University authorities. The T-Square Society started with 14 charter members, one alumna resident member, and two honorary members.”

Helen Smith, Secretary T-Square Society, Colleges of Engineering and Architecture, University of Michigan

A member of T-Square, Hazel Quick, worked with Melton and Counts to create society bylaws, membership application forms, and a logo for their new organization, but ASWEA never took off. Thirty years later, Counts became a founding member of the Society of Women Engineers, and Quick joined the SWE Detroit section in 1952.

A professor from Stanford also had a progressive outlook on admitting women into engineering societies.

February 7, 1919

“Now as regards the formation of a separate engineering organization which you contemplate, I must confess that I am not in favor of such a move if you can get the young men in your institution to take the proper step which, in my opinion, consists in admitting you to full membership in the existing organization. For years, I have favored the admission of women to membership in the American Society of Civil Engineers, and can see no reason why there should be any discrimination on account of sex.”

Very sincerely yours,

Charles David Marx, Professor of civil engineering, Stanford University, and past president of the American Society of Civil Engineers

SWE’s archives contain the results of the survey, which identified 139 women from 23 institutions who had taken college courses in engineering or architecture.

Read more about the SWE archives in SWE Magazine’s article, “The Archives and the Archivist: Sharing SWE’s Story Together.” Below is an excerpt.

The SWE archives, which, since 1993, have been housed in the Walter P. Reuther Library at Wayne State University in Detroit, are hard to fathom. In terms of their sheer physicality, the archives represent a substantial body of materials that occupies 270 linear feet of shelf space — which Eller English says translates rather nicely into the contents of 270 banker’s storage boxes.

In addition to that, SWE separately maintains thousands of print photographs, slides, and negatives; audio recordings, digital files, digital photographs, and/or digitized versions of print photographs that Eller English has scanned; and electronic files from the past 10 years of SWE history — accessible via computer.

As a rule, SWE members collected whatever they thought might, one day, have historical value. And the results of their efforts are awe inspiring: tens of thousands of documents representing 67 years of the Society of Women Engineers’ organizational history. Imagine box, after box, after box brimming with national and sectional board meeting minutes, conference proceedings, and program books; spreadsheets, annual reports, financial audits, speeches, personal journals, biographies, award applications, and award recipient write-ups; membership rosters, private correspondence, corporate correspondence, newsletters, assorted publications, fliers, pamphlets, brochures, meeting discussion notes, oral history transcripts, newspaper and magazine clippings, press releases, and all sorts of associated ephemera: buttons, trinkets, and promotional items — and you start to appreciate the overwhelming abundance of “stuff” preserved in SWE’s archives.

Find more information about SWE’s past on our history page.


  • SWE Blog

    SWE Blog provides up-to-date information and news about the Society and how our members are making a difference every day. You’ll find stories about SWE members, engineering, technology, and other STEM-related topics.